8 Comments
User's avatar
mole's avatar

my partner and i always discuss the billboards whenever we drive through the city, noticing the new additions and updates and wondering what the companies are even trying to say with each one. your essay is really insightful with pulling together how the billboards are winking, making inside jokes, and vice-signaling in this weird combination of ragebait, humble-brag, sheepishness, self-consciousness/awareness, etc.

Expand full comment
afra's avatar

Thank you! The terms “humble-brag” and “sheepishness” are incredibly insightful! I can definitely sense the hidden message.

Expand full comment
Bri Boone's avatar

everything about this piece is absolutely brilliant

Expand full comment
afra's avatar

thank you thank you this really means a lot

Expand full comment
Kurt Shoens's avatar

Thank you for this article. Your descriptions of the billboards makes me feel sad. Imagine the marketing people deciding to spend this way when the company is trying to figure out its place in the world. And truly, even if the market for (say) large language model AI realizes the expectations of the tech industry, most of these companies will vanish without a trace. In the meantime, so there's so much reckless hope sustaining these ventures.

Expand full comment
afra's avatar

I agree with you. There is a sense of sheer nihilism and opportunism in those billboards, although unfortunately, they are a part of the Bay Area economy. We really need to challenge ourselves to do better and ask those in marketing to stop capitalizing and feeling good about rage-baiting and deliberate moral ambiguity.

Expand full comment
Nancy Friedman's avatar

I recently counted seven AI billboards on the eastbound approach to the Bay Bridge, and I probably missed (or misinterpreted) a few more. I also take note of SF Muni bus-shelter ads, like the one I saw last week for ElevenLabs that read "THIS POSTER SOUNDS BETTER IN A BRITISH ACCENT." It's for AI-enabled voices, of course.

Expand full comment
afra's avatar

ok i need to admit this one is good

Expand full comment