Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Virginia Postrel's avatar

Stanford would never admit an Iowa corn farmer and an Atlanta aquarium director into its hallowed precincts, and that explains a lot.

As someone who was raised to be the last Victorian I’d like to hear more on that theme.

Great post.

Jack Shanahan's avatar

Thank you!

I realize the deeper cultural differences concerning views of AI between the two countries will take years to analyze fully, but in addition to what you described here, it seems to me that until about 5 years ago AI development in the U.S. was happening relatively “normally”.

Then as the AI community in SV exploded, the middle ground gave way to boomer and doomer bookends.

When combined with the perception of a tech bro soliloquy (“you’ll take it and you’ll like it!”) instead of a two-way conversation with the American people, the enthusiasm level for AI began to drop. Rapidly.

Does it recover? I believe so, but not without rebuilding the middle ground—acknowledging the full spectrum: the AI great, the good, the bad, the ugly, and the potentially catastrophic.

30 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?